• Home
  • Product
    • Li-ion Tamer Gen 3 (System-wide and Scalable)
    • Electric Vehicles
    • Li-ion Tamer Gen 2+ (Sensor-only)
  • Markets
  • News & Events
  • Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Li-ion TamerLi-ion Tamer
Li-ion TamerLi-ion Tamer
  • Home
  • Product
    • Li-ion Tamer Gen 3 (System-wide and Scalable)
    • Electric Vehicles
    • Li-ion Tamer Gen 2+ (Sensor-only)
  • Markets
  • News & Events
  • Resources
  • About
  • Contact

APS Battery Fire Report Overview

APS Battery Fire Report Overview

September 21, 2020 Posted by Steve Cummings
lithium-ion battery fire

The Arizona Public Service (APS) electric utility sustained a lithium-ion battery fire which caused severe injuries to several firefighters in April of 2019. More than a year later, in August of 2020, three reports were released detailing the events of the APS battery fire. The reports are linked below and were written by:

  • DNV-GL (contracted by APS)
  • Exponent (contracted by LG Chem)
  • Underwriters Laboratory (UL)

Brief report summary

The UL report does not try to diagnose a root cause of the event, and instead focuses largely on the first responders, how to learn from the event, and how to improve the safety of lithium-ion battery energy storage systems moving forward.

On the other hand, the DNV-GL and Exponent report are at odds with each other. The Exponent report has a detailed, pre-emptive letter from LG Chem that particularly calls out the DNV-GL report saying things such as “DNV-GL ignored other experts’ views and key evidence without explanation” and “independent experts retained by LG Chem believe the evidence rules out DNV-GL’s theory”.

What are DNV-GL and LG Chem disagreeing over?

In short, DNV-GL and LG Chem (Exponent) are disagreeing over the root cause of the event.

Exponent, in a section titled Environmental Data and System Analysis (pg. 117 through 135), details how the lack of environmental control could have caused the initial failure and indicates key conclusions, such as:

  • Temperature and humidity sensors were not properly placed to measure extremes improperly placed sensor locations to measure extreme temperature and humidity
  • Large temperature differences between available sensing points was observed
  • The dew point temperature gradually increasing over time, indicating changing environmental conditions and not a truly closed loop system
  • Relative humidity regularly exceeded 80%
  • The role of high relative humidity and/or condensation on electronics in the BESS cannot be ruled out as a contributor to the root cause of the initial failure.
Learn how Li-ion Tamer can sense relative humidity and temperature

DNV-GL, on pages 24 through 30, details why the primary contribution to the failure was an internal short circuit caused by the dendritic growth of the electrode materials. There is a very detailed failure analysis within this section, however, Exponent refutes many of these points with a detailed failure analysis of their own on pages 94 through 116.

How the UL Report differs from the DNV-GL and LG Chem reports

While the DNV-GL and LG Chem report largely discuss the root cause of the event, the UL report does not address this issue and focuses on the fire responders’ procedure, including discussions around the fire detection and suppression scheme and the information available to the first responders. Contributing factors, as discussed by UL in their report, are detailed below:

  • Improperly trained HAZMAT team
  • No flammable gas detection in ESS
  • Lack of information delivery to HAZMAT team because of ESS communication system failure
  • No emergency response plan available prior to the incident
  • No NFPA 68/69 compliance
Learn how Li-ion Tamer can sense flammable gas in Energy Storage Applications

Key takeaways

  • Lack of agreement amongst ESS Subject Matter Experts means more need more redundancy in detection and mitigation
  • All three reports summarize the ineffectiveness of fire suppression in ESS applications
  • Application-specific gas detection solutions need to be considered during ESS design
  • Ventilation and deflagration solutions need to be standard for stationary ESS applications
Contact us now to discuss how the Li-ion Tamer product can help prevent battery fires
Share
9

About Steve Cummings

Steve Cummings is the Director of the Sensors Business Unit at Nexceris, LLC. He is focused on the development of enhanced safety for lithium-ion batteries and has extensive experience in testing and characterizing failures modes of battery cells. Throughout his career, he has developed and launched several new products for monitoring battery systems.

You also might be interested in

The Top 10 Lithium Ion Battery Regulations and Why They Are Important to Everyone

The Top 10 Lithium Ion Battery Regulations and Why They Are Important to Everyone

May 11, 2017

Lithium ion batteries are under increased scrutiny due to high-profile[...]

Showcasing Li-Ion Battery Sensor Concepts at Electric & Hybrid Marine World Expo 2017

Showcasing Li-Ion Battery Sensor Concepts at Electric & Hybrid Marine World Expo 2017

May 24, 2017

Nexceris will be attending the Electric & Hybrid Marine World[...]

Li-Ion Battery Safety Article Featured in Electric & Hybrid Marine Technology International

Li-Ion Battery Safety Article Featured in Electric & Hybrid Marine Technology International

Apr 24, 2017

Applications Engineer Nick Frank has written an article for the[...]

Recent Posts

  • Li-ion Tamer Gen2+ Sensor Receives California State Fire Marshal Listing
  • Li-ion Tamer Receives UL Mark
  • Off-gas Detection System Receives Favorable Test Result
  • National Lab Testing Demonstrates Value in Early Detection
  • Today’s data centers need multi-layered protection

Categories

  • Battery Regulations
  • Certifications
  • Electric Vehicles
  • Korean Battery Market
  • Li-Ion Battery Safety
  • Li-Ion Battery Testing
  • Li-ion Tamer Awards
  • Marine Battery Safety
  • Stationary Energy Storage
  • Uncategorized

Tags

Awards Battery Failure Stages Battery Safety battery testing CE Certifications Cleanie Awards DOE E&HM2017 Energy innovation Energy Storage Association ESA ETL EV Free consultation green energy Li-ion Li-Ion Batteries Li-Ion Battery Li-ion battery safety Li-ion Tamer Marine Marine Battery safety Mitigating Actions Off-gas Regulations Runaway Event Solar Solar energy Stationary Energy Storage UL video

Archives

  • January 2025
  • November 2024
  • July 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • March 2021
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • November 2019
  • September 2019
  • June 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • August 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • January 2017

Contact

  • Li-ion Tamer®
  • 404 Enterprise Drive, Lewis Center OH 43035
  • +1 614-842-6606
  • info@liiontamer.com

Customer Service

Updates
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Contact Us

© 2025 · Li-ion Tamer®